FREE Shipping on $100+ per Shipment
Order 2026 Advent Calendar with Free Shipping!
Skip to navigationSkip to contentSkip to search

Caramel & Butterscotch

Showing 33 Product Results

Load Previous
Dark Salted Caramel

Dark Salted Caramel

Create a Box
Dark Butterscotch Square

Dark Butterscotch Square

Create a Box
Milk Butterscotch Square

Milk Butterscotch Square

Create a Box
Milk Butterchew®

Milk Butterchew®

Create a Box
Dark Butterchew®

Dark Butterchew®

Create a Box
Milk Caramel Pattie

Milk Caramel Pattie

Create a Box
Dark Caramel Pattie

Dark Caramel Pattie

Create a Box
Vanilla Nut Caramel

Vanilla Nut Caramel

Create a Box
Milk Double Caramel

Milk Double Caramel

Create a Box
Milk Almond Caramel

Milk Almond Caramel

Create a Box
Milk Almond Square

Milk Almond Square

Create a Box
Milk Pecan Bud

Milk Pecan Bud

Create a Box
Dark Pecan Bud

Dark Pecan Bud

Create a Box
Milk Almond Bud

Milk Almond Bud

Create a Box
Polar Bear Paw®

Polar Bear Paw®

Create a Box
Out of Stock
Scotchmallow® Assortment

Scotchmallow® Assortment

4.4
$25.00Scotchmallow® Assortment Current price: $25.00
Out of Stock
Dark Coffee Scotchmallow®

Dark Coffee Scotchmallow®

4.7
$13.25Dark Coffee Scotchmallow® Current price: $13.25
Out of Stock
Milk Caramel Apple Scotchmallow®

Milk Caramel Apple Scotchmallow®

4.3
$13.25Milk Caramel Apple Scotchmallow® Current price: $13.25
Out of Stock
Milk & Dark Scotchmallow®

Milk & Dark Scotchmallow®

4.3
$35.50Milk & Dark Scotchmallow® Current price: $35.50
Out of Stock
All Milk Scotchmallow® Box

All Milk Scotchmallow® Box

4.3
$36.50All Milk Scotchmallow® Box Current price: $36.50
Out of Stock
All Milk Butterchew® Box

All Milk Butterchew® Box

4.7
$36.50All Milk Butterchew® Box Current price: $36.50
Out of Stock
All Polar Bear Paw® Box

All Polar Bear Paw® Box

4.7
$36.50All Polar Bear Paw® Box Current price: $36.50
Out of Stock
All Dark Pecan Bud Box

All Dark Pecan Bud Box

4.7
$36.50All Dark Pecan Bud Box Current price: $36.50
Out of Stock
Dark Scotchmallow®

Dark Scotchmallow®