See’s Candies Top 10 Caramel and Butterscotch Candies

Feast your eyes on this! Our trusty taste-testers sampled and selected our top See’s caramel candies and butterscotch delights. They take their jobs seriously savoring See’s caramel and butterscotch candy in the most delicious way.

Our experts (and See’s superfans) have compiled these Top 10 treats for sweet inspiration. Get your taste buds ready to discover the best of the best in our mouthwatering caramel and butterscotch category. 

Top 10 See’s Caramel and Butterscotch Candies

1. Milk Butterscotch Square
   A great place to kick off the list is with our ultimate classic. This scrumptious Milk Butterscotch Square is coated in silky milk chocolate for the best of both worlds. With a mix of firm brown sugar, vanilla and heavy cream, it is satisfyingly indulgent with the oh-so-smooth taste of a winner.

2. Milk Butterchew®
   Next up, let’s discuss the can’t-resist (and very quintessential) See’s caramel. Our Milk Butterchew® is blended with buttery brown sugar caramel and drenched in smooth milk chocolate that will melt your heart — and in your mouth.

3. Dark Scotchmallow®
   This icon is timeless for a reason. Everyone loves the Dark Scotchmallow®! Bite into a layer of fluffy, honey marshmallow and buttery caramel candy, and you’ll experience a double-decker of pure deliciousness. This classic piece is wrapped in mouthwatering dark chocolate for a fantastic finale.

4. Polar Bear Paw®
   When this seasonal sweet comes out of hibernation, See’s fans do anything to get their paws on them. Roasted, salted peanuts and buttery caramel candy are covered in smooth white chocolate to ensure that Polar Bear Paws® are ready to devour.

5. Pecan Buds
   Sometimes even the experts get stumped — smooth milk chocolate or rich dark chocolate… who could decide? Our crunchy, chewy and rich Milk Pecan Buds and Dark Pecan Buds share the ribbon for the number 5 spot. If you’re looking for a delicious duo, prepare to experience these premium pecan halves with buttery caramel.

6. Butterscotch Lollypops
   Channel your inner child with our fan-favorite treats for all ages. These great on-the-go Butterscotch Lollypops, made with heavy cream and butter, are considered the Top See’s butterscotch candies, because they never go out of style!

7. Milk Caramel Pattie
   Look no further than this delectable mainstay to satisfy your caramel candy dreams. A buttery vanilla caramel covered in milk chocolate, our Milk Caramel Pattie is simply irresistible. This flavorful concoction is featured in many classic assortments and is a no-brainer for the Top See’s caramel candies list.

8. Dark Salted Caramel
   When you add a dash of sea salt to rich dark chocolate and brown sugar caramel, magic starts to happen. Indulge in our Dark Salted Caramel to discover the perfectly mouthwatering pair of salty and sweet.

9. Milk Double Caramel
   If you’re ready for a crave-worthy caramel, don’t miss our Milk Double Caramel. This milk chocolate-covered piece has both chocolate butter caramel and creamy vanilla caramel when you can’t pick just one flavor of caramel candy. Get ready to savor the taste twice.

10. Milk Almond Square
    Rounding out our Top 10 list is the Milk Almond Square. Is it crunchy? Yes. Chewy? You bet. Nutty? Absolutely. In fact, it’s a trifecta of tastiness. Half-dipped in silky milk chocolate with roasted almonds and vanilla caramel, this candy always hits the sweet spot.

Grab Our Limited-Time For the Love of Caramel Box!

Curated with love and confection, our new fan-favorite For the Love of Caramel Box is a crowd-pleaser. Sample some of our best-selling treats like Dark Scotchmallow®, Milk Butterchew® and more. Are you feeling generous? Then find it in your heart to give this assortment of buttery, rich treats to someone who will appreciate it as much as you do! 

Shop See’s Caramels

Related Topics:

• See’s Top 10 Dark Chocolate Candies

• See’s Top 10 Milk Chocolate Candies

• Mother’s Day Gift Ideas